Apparently, there’s a ton of people still hitting this post, despite it being written in 2010.
Folks, I am very aware that Killer Shrimp has reopened in the Marina. Thank you but there’s no need to let me know… I LIVE HERE. 🙂
For those not aware, Killer Shrimp closed back in the late 2000’s at it’s original location on Washington Blvd, was going to move to Chicago in the early 2010s, then opened a new location on the Marina several years later after what I was told was a change in the owner’s personal situation.
Y’all are reading the very first post of a very old set of seven posts about our quest to recreate the recipe. Here’s the seventh & final post that was written back in June 2012:
ORIGINAL POST (4/24/10):
A friend of mine from work, Stephanie Lemus, (who incidentally was one of the 100 people selected to compete in this year’s $1,000,000 Pillsbury Bake Off for her original recipe for Candied Bacon & Apple Canapes) forwarded me the recipe for what was supposed to be the broth from “Killer Shrimp”, a rather famous place to eat in Marina Del Rey that closed down a few years ago.
Many folks – particularly single folk – would go there and eat the one thing they sold: Shrimp in a spicy cajun style broth. They served it with your choice of french bread, rice, or noodles but that was all they served. One dish, 3 ways. And it was good enough to run a business on for at least a decade or so.
Sadly, Killer Shrimp is no more. Reportedly there’s a place called Jack Shrimp in Newport Beach that has an identical recipe (supposedly a brother of the Killer Shrimp owner) but beyond that, there’s no where in LA to get this stuff… unless you make it yourself.
I’ve looked at the recipe Steph gave me and compared it to the comments & advice about similar recipes from several locations (references below) and came up with the aggregate you see below. Basically, I used the ‘wisdom of crowds’ to come up with what I think is the closest thing to the original Killer Shrimp recipe. For instance, it seems universally recognized by those that have tried this recipe that the chicken broth should be ‘low sodium’… that ‘thyme’ needs to be added… that red pepper flakes need to be added… that beer gets used instead of white wine (although I disagree on this point – being that the origination of this substitution seems to be a single comment made on one web site without any sort of corroboration)… that the amount of tomato paste should be reduced to 3 oz… etc. etc.
One very important thing we’ve learned is that there is no getting around the cooking time. You absolutely must cook this for 3 hours or more even if you cut the spices.
Anyway – here it is so far. Consider this a beta. It’s not perfect yet. My wife and I are still testing some things, specifically the usage of lemon, the trade off between using white wine or beer, adding sea salt, etc.:
- ½ small onion, diced
- 1 celery rib, diced
- 5 cloves Garlic, minced
- ½ cup (1 stick) unsalted butter (was 1 cup butter)
- 2 quarts low-sodium chicken broth (can be overly salty if not low-sodium)
- 1 ½ tablespoon rosemary (was 2 tablespoons rosemary)
- 2 teaspoons dried thyme
- 1 teaspoon ground black pepper
- 1 teaspoon celery seed
- 1/2 teaspoon fennel seed
- 1 teaspoon red pepper flakes
- 8oz clam juice (was 1 cup clam juice supposed to change to 2 cups but switched back to 8 oz)
- 3 tablespoons (3 oz) of tomato paste (was 1/2 (6 ounce) can tomato paste)
- 1 cup white wine (or beer)
- 1 ½ pounds shrimp, with tails
- Optional: Frank’s Red Hot Sauce
- 1 (1 pound) loaf French bread
- Fry onion, celery, garlic in the butter until fragrant and soft in a large pot.
- Take all the spices (rosemary, thyme, pepper, celery seed, fennel seed, pepper flakes) and cut/crush them enough that they remain whole but are broken to more easily release flavor.
- Pour in broth, and mix in rosemary, thyme, pepper, celery seed, fennel seed, clam juice, pepper flakes, & tomato paste. Place cover on pot to maintain consistency.
- Bring to a boil, reduce heat to low, and simmer 1 hour, stirring occasionally.
- Stir beer into the broth mixture and continue to simmer and occasionally stir 2 hours.
- Just before serving, stir in shrimp. Continue cooking 3 minutes, or until shrimp are opaque.
- Serve with bread.
- Comments from one posting:
- Too much butter. It should be 1 stick (1/2 cup) at the most and some people may find they would rather use less.
- The shrimp MUST have the whole skin on. The flavor that the shrimp peels adds to the mix is essential, yet indefinable.
- Double the amount of clam juice to 16 oz
- Reduce the Rosemary by 1/3 and double the amount of fennel, add 1 tsp dried thyme
- Reduce the tomato paste to 3 TBSP
- Add salt, preferably sea salt
- Add 1 tsp of red pepper flakes (or to taste)
- Add hot sauce to taste. Finally, there is a secret ingredient involved, which I am not prepared to divulge. But the above will get you close.